Skip to content
All resources
Practical guide

Switching Websites Without Losing Your Domain, Email, or Google Listing

Four things have to survive the move. The website is only one of them.

A glowing ribbon carries a brass signpost, an envelope and a map pin from an old browser window to a brighter new one.

Quick answer

A website move replaces one thing. Your domain, DNS records, email and Google listing are separate and usually sit in separate accounts. Find out who holds each, copy the DNS records, move any email bundled with old hosting, then switch the website records and test before cancelling anything.

In this article

Most owners who put off replacing a website are not attached to the old one. They are worried about what breaks on the way out: the address customers already know, the email the business runs on, and the Google listing people find first.

Those worries are reasonable, and each has a specific answer. A website move goes wrong when all of these get treated as one thing called "the website." They are separate, they usually sit in separate accounts, and only one of them is being replaced.

Four separate things

WhatWhat it isWhere it usually lives
Domain nameYour address, such as yourbusiness.com, rented by the yearA registrar account
DNS recordsThe directions that send web visitors and email to the right placeThe registrar, the old web host, or a separate DNS service
EmailThe mailboxes at your domainA mail provider, or bundled with the old hosting
Google listingYour Business Profile in Search and MapsA Google account, with owners and managers

The website itself sits with the host or builder you are leaving. Changing websites means changing where one or two DNS records point. Nothing else has to move unless it was bundled with the old site.

Find out who holds each one

Do this before you sign anything or cancel anything.

The domain. Ask which company it is registered with, whose name and email are on that account, and when it renews. If the answer is "my web person has it," ask for it to be moved into an account you control, or at least get the login. This is an ordinary request, and it is easier to make while you are still a paying customer.

You do not usually need to transfer a domain to a different registrar to change websites. Leaving it where it is and changing its records is quicker and carries less risk. A transfer can take several days, and a domain that was registered or transferred recently is typically locked against another transfer for a month or two.

The email. Find out where the mailboxes actually are. If you sign in through a separate mail service, your email is independent of the website and only its DNS records need protecting. If your email came "free with hosting," the mailboxes live on the server you are about to cancel, and they go when it goes. Move them to a mail provider first.

The Google listing. Sign in to Google and open the people and access settings on your Business Profile. They show who is an owner and who is a manager. You want to be the primary owner. If a former employee or an old agency holds that role, ask them to transfer it; Google also has a process for requesting ownership when they cannot be reached. The listing is not tied to your web host. After a move, the only thing to change on it is the website link, and only if the address changed.

Copy the records before anything changes

Ask whoever manages your DNS for a complete export or a screenshot of the current records. The ones that matter most:

  • MX records, which route your email
  • TXT records for mail (SPF, DKIM and DMARC), which help keep your messages out of spam folders
  • Records for other services, such as online ordering, a booking page or a store on a subdomain

If the move changes your nameservers, which hands DNS to a different company, every one of these has to be recreated on the new side first. A missed MX record is the usual way email "disappears" during a website launch. If the move only changes the records that point to the website, the mail records are left alone.

Keep the old addresses working

Customers have your old pages bookmarked. Your menu page is linked from other listings. A QR code is printed on the table cards.

List the pages that get used: menu, hours, contact, ordering, events. Ask the new provider to redirect each old address to its replacement. Then check the links you do not control from the website: your Google listing, your Facebook page, review and directory sites, the chamber listing, and anything in print.

The order that keeps things working

1. Get control of the domain and confirm the renewal date.

2. Confirm where email lives. Move it off the old host first if it is bundled.

3. Save a copy of every DNS record.

4. Save your content from the old site: text, photos, menus, and any customer or subscriber list you are entitled to export.

5. Build and review the new site at a temporary address.

6. Switch the website records on a quiet day, early in the week.

7. Test from a phone on cellular data. The site loads at an https address with no security warning. The old menu link lands somewhere useful. An email sent to your business address from a personal account arrives, and your reply gets back. Your own contact form reaches you.

8. Update the website link on the Google listing and other profiles if it changed.

9. Keep the old hosting for one more billing period. Cancel after a week or two of normal email and no surprises.

DNS changes can take from a few minutes to a day or two to reach everyone, so some customers may see the old site for a while. That is expected. Leaving the old site up through that window means nobody sees an error.

How this works on Porchlight

Porchlight sites go live on your own domain, and our terms list the domain as yours. Setup includes a one-time fix of your Google listing. On Connected and up, later updates go through the Google account you connect, which stays yours. Porchlight does not host your mailboxes, so your business email stays where it is, and the records that route it need to come through the switch untouched.

Leaving is covered too. After 12 months of paid service you can ask for a static copy of your pages, text and images at no charge. The manager and the connections only work on Porchlight. What a small-business website really costs puts that boundary next to the other ways of buying a site.

Knowing who holds your domain and where your email lives is worth an hour whether or not you ever switch. If you are weighing a move, the free Front Door Check shows what customers see on your current site and listing first.